fbpx
  • Subscribe & Support
  • Print Edition
    • Get Home Delivery
    • Read ePaper Online
    • Newsstand Locations
  • HV1 Magazines
  • Contact
    • Advertise
    • Submit Your Event
    • Customer Support
    • Submit A News Tip
    • Send Letter to the Editor
    • Where’s My Paper?
  • Our Newsletters
  • Manage HV1 Account
  • Free HV1 Trial
Hudson Valley One
  • News
    • Schools
    • Business
    • Sports
    • Crime
    • Politics & Government
  • What’s UP
    • Calendar Of Events
    • Subscribe to the What’s UP newsletter
  • Opinion
    • Letters
    • Columns
  • Local
    • Special Sections
    • Local History
  • Marketplace
    • All Classified Ads
    • Post a Classified Ad
  • Obituaries
  • Log Out
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Schools
    • Business
    • Sports
    • Crime
    • Politics & Government
  • What’s UP
    • Calendar Of Events
    • Subscribe to the What’s UP newsletter
  • Opinion
    • Letters
    • Columns
  • Local
    • Special Sections
    • Local History
  • Marketplace
    • All Classified Ads
    • Post a Classified Ad
  • Obituaries
  • Log Out
No Result
View All Result
Hudson Valley One
No Result
View All Result

Gardiner Town Board to reconsider “primary residence” requirement for short-term rental law

by Frances Marion Platt
March 26, 2021
in Politics & Government
0
Hudson Valley tenants and landlords cope with loss of income, housing uncertainty

Municipal discussions held via Zoom don’t allow much provision for participants to wave torches and pitchforks, but operators of short-term rentals (STRs) in Gardiner wielded plenty of angry comments in the chat function of the special meeting called by the Town Board on March 16 to continue shaping the proposed Short-Term Rental Law. No votes were ultimately taken, and changes to the current draft were deferred to the board’s regular April meetings, but several members indicated a willingness to tweak a few of the proposed law’s least popular provisions before passage.

Much of the audience’s ire was focused on deputy supervisor Laura Walls, who alone continued to urge that the law as drafted (viewable at www.townofgardiner.org/short-term-rental-law) be passed unchanged, with the option of amending it in a year’s time if necessary, based on its observed effectiveness. Walls has consistently taken the position that the trend for turning former residential housing into tourist accommodations is a major factor in making home purchases and long-term rentals in Gardiner unaffordable, and that local quality of life suffers as well when renters are transient.

“You’re taking a family home off the market that a family could live in, so that they can have a short-term rental. But visitors come and visitors go. We want people to live here who will vest here,” Walls argued. “If people are coming and going, you don’t have a neighborhood.”

Town supervisor Marybeth Majestic noted that Gardiner was Number One on the list of most expensive communities to live in, according to Ulster County’s most recently released Housing Report. “That’s not something to be proud of,” she admitted. Other board members, however, questioned whether a causal relationship between STR conversions and rising home and rental prices had been definitively established. Councilman Franco Carucci said that STRs, with about 100 registered units, only constitute about four percent of the housing stock in Gardiner at present.

The meeting was convened to address five aspects of the proposed law that had drawn particular fire from current STR operators during the public hearing phase, which was closed earlier this month. The first of these, and the one on which board members seemed inclined to have the most wiggle room, was the provision that the STR must be the owner’s primary residence in order to qualify for a permit. Many public comments have stressed that renting out a whole house for part of the year while temporarily living elsewhere was the sole means by which some owners can afford to keep a house in Gardiner, which they intend to use as their primary residence at some future date.

The board floated the possibility of changing the law’s verbiage to require that a whole-house STR be the owner’s “legal” residence rather than “primary” residence. “There are definitions [of legal residence] that don’t specify that you have to spend most of your time there,” suggested councilman David Dukler. “It can be where you pay taxes, have a mortgage, where you vote.”

“If we make this very restrictive, we may put some good STR owners right out of business,” Carucci argued. “We can use fines and penalties to punish the bad actors. We should allow one short-term rental right out of the gate, whether you live in Gardiner or you live in Brooklyn.” He recommended that ownership by an LLC be prohibited outright, in order to curb investors from outside the region from buying up housing stock to convert to STRs strictly for profit.

Discussion of another objection frequently raised by local STR owners, the 100-day annual limit for whole-house rentals, was tabled until after the “primary residence” question is resolved. Current STR operators have also demanded that their rental businesses be “grandfathered,” in order to avoid jeopardizing contractual obligations with renters already incurred for the near future. Supervisor Majestic said that the board should consider delaying the law’s effective date or offering current registered operators a “grace period” to resolve such commitments, but “not grandfathering, because that implies in perpetuity.”

Another possibility raised by multiple board members was placing a cap on the total number of STR permits issued in the town in any given year, at a level that would discourage new investors without driving out any current operators. Such a provision is not included in the current draft of the law.

Tags: members
Join the family! Grab a free month of HV1 from the folks who have brought you substantive local news since 1972. We made it 50 years thanks to support from readers like you. Help us keep real journalism alive.
- Geddy Sveikauskas, Publisher

Frances Marion Platt

Frances Marion Platt has been a feature writer (and copyeditor) for Ulster Publishing since 1994, under both her own name and the nom de plume Zhemyna Jurate. Her reporting beats include Gardiner and Rosendale, the arts and a bit of local history. In 2011 she took up Syd M’s mantle as film reviewer for Alm@nac Weekly, and she hopes to return to doing more of that as HV1 recovers from the shock of COVID-19. A Queens native, Platt moved to New Paltz in 1971 to earn a BA in English and minor in Linguistics at SUNY. Her first writing/editing gig was with the Ulster County Artist magazine. In the 1980s she was assistant editor of The Independent Film and Video Monthly for five years, attended Heartwood Owner/Builder School, designed and built a timberframe house in Gardiner. Her son Evan Pallor was born in 1995. Alternating with her journalism career, she spent many years doing development work – mainly grantwriting – for a variety of not-for-profit organizations, including six years at Scenic Hudson. She currently lives in Kingston.

Related Posts

Police departments, rescue squads reorganize for socially distanced first response
Politics & Government

Eminent-domain powers tested in appellate court

July 3, 2025
Words aplenty fly in Woodstock primary
Politics & Government

Likely new Wooodstock town supervisor sweeps Democratic primary

July 2, 2025
Korolkoff-Nagele recount
Politics & Government

Korolkoff-Nagele recount

June 26, 2025
Is the New Paltz supervisor race finished?
Politics & Government

Is the New Paltz supervisor race finished?

June 25, 2025
Letters to the editor: September 11, 2024 (Winston Farm, Shady dump, hostages and more)
Politics & Government

Public concerns outweigh support for Winston Farm proposal

June 25, 2025
Gotto, Rogers in Democratic primary contest for New Paltz town supervisor
Politics & Government

Tim Roger’s acceptance announcement for supervisor primary in New Paltz

June 25, 2025
Next Post
Debate over later school start time continues in Onteora

Debate over later school start time continues in Onteora

Weather

Kingston, NY
73°
Clear
5:25 am8:35 pm EDT
Feels like: 73°F
Wind: 2mph WSW
Humidity: 69%
Pressure: 30.05"Hg
UV index: 0
SunMonTue
91°F / 70°F
86°F / 72°F
86°F / 66°F
powered by Weather Atlas

Subscribe

Independent. Local. Substantive. Subscribe now.

×
We've expanded coverage and need your support. Subscribe now for unlimited access -- free article(s) remain for the month.
View Subscription Offers Sign In
  • Subscribe & Support
  • Print Edition
  • HV1 Magazines
  • Contact
  • Our Newsletters
  • Manage HV1 Account
  • Free HV1 Trial

© 2022 Ulster Publishing

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Schools
    • Business
    • Sports
    • Crime
    • Politics & Government
  • What’s Happening
    • Calendar Of Events
    • Art
    • Books
    • Kids
    • Lifestyle & Wellness
    • Food & Drink
    • Music
    • Nature
    • Stage & Screen
  • Opinions
    • Letters
    • Columns
  • Local
    • Special Sections
    • Local History
  • Marketplace
    • All Classified Ads
    • Post a Classified Ad
  • Obituaries
  • Subscribe & Support
  • Contact Us
    • Customer Support
    • Advertise
    • Submit A News Tip
  • Print Edition
    • Read ePaper Online
    • Newsstand Locations
    • Where’s My Paper
  • HV1 Magazines
  • Manage HV1 Account
  • Log In
  • Free HV1 Trial
  • Subscribe to Our Newsletters
    • Hey Kingston
    • New Paltz Times
    • Woodstock Times
    • Week in Review

© 2022 Ulster Publishing