fbpx
  • Subscribe & Support
  • Print Edition
    • Get Home Delivery
    • Read ePaper Online
    • Newsstand Locations
  • HV1 Magazines
  • Contact
    • Advertise
    • Submit Your Event
    • Customer Support
    • Submit A News Tip
    • Send Letter to the Editor
    • Where’s My Paper?
  • Our Newsletters
  • Manage HV1 Account
  • Free HV1 Trial
Hudson Valley One
  • News
    • Schools
    • Business
    • Sports
    • Crime
    • Politics & Government
  • What’s UP
    • Calendar Of Events
    • Subscribe to the What’s UP newsletter
  • Opinion
    • Letters
    • Columns
  • Local
    • Special Sections
    • Local History
  • Marketplace
    • All Classified Ads
    • Post a Classified Ad
  • Obituaries
  • Log Out
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Schools
    • Business
    • Sports
    • Crime
    • Politics & Government
  • What’s UP
    • Calendar Of Events
    • Subscribe to the What’s UP newsletter
  • Opinion
    • Letters
    • Columns
  • Local
    • Special Sections
    • Local History
  • Marketplace
    • All Classified Ads
    • Post a Classified Ad
  • Obituaries
  • Log Out
No Result
View All Result
Hudson Valley One
No Result
View All Result

Former Saugerties police chief’s $2.5 million defamation lawsuit dismissed in court

by Crispin Kott
April 7, 2025
in Politics & Government
0

A $2.5 million lawsuit brought against three Town of Saugerties officials by former Saugerties Police Chief Joseph Sinagra was dismissed last week in Ulster County Supreme Court for being “not actionable in the context of a defamation action.”

In the 12-page decision handed down on Monday, March 31, Supreme Court Judge Sharon Graff said Sinagra’s July 2024 lawsuit against Supervisor Fred Costello, and councilmen Mike Ivino and Zach Horton had expressed their opinions rather than fact in discussing the events leading up to and following his retirement.

“In this regard,” Graff said, “… Costello’s statement that ‘…the controversy and Sinagra’s handling of it played a role in how well the town police department was functioning,’ Ivino’s statement that ‘…policies that weren’t effective and just caused animosity’ … and Horton’s statement that ‘Not that I like to speak for other board members here but I think I can confidently say that it’s not only my goal and commitment but the commitment of every member up here to bring integrity back to this department (and) to restore stability within the department,’ are, in each instance at most, simply expressions of opinions’.”

Sinagra retired from the Saugerties Police Department inSeptember 2023 in the wake of a report by New York State Attorney General Letitia James’ Law Enforcement Misconduct Investigative Office (LEMIO) which covered multiple complaints against officer Dion Johnson, including allegations of harassment and sexual assault. Town board members pointed to the report and the department’s response as a primary motivation for placing Sinagra on administrative leave over the summer of 2023. Sinagra maintained that he hadn’t done anything wrong.

In the filing, Sinagra was not only seeking the stated $2.5 million, but also an award of damages at trial commensurate with loss of income, legal expenses and damage to his reputation. The filing cited statements made by the three members of the town board in local media, including Hudson Valley One and claimed they yielded “unsavory or evil opinion in the minds of a significant number of people in the community.”

Ivino shared a press release on social media on April 1.

“The attorneys representing the Town of Saugerties and board in this matter were very optimistic of the outcome and is now supported by the findings of the court,” he said. “Judge Sharon A. Graff credited our two primary, dispositive arguments: (1) that several of Sinagra’s claims are time-barred because the alleged defamatory statements were made more than 90 days before he filed the notice of claim, depriving the court of subject matter jurisdiction; and (2) that the remaining statements are ‘at most, simply expressions of opinions about how the police department was impacted in general as a result of the Johnson investigation and how best to address that impact.’ The language in the statements were also so limited that no reasonable reader would be led to believe they were conveying facts about plaintiff, ‘much less than they were ‘reasonably susceptible of a defamatory connotation’.”

Join the family! Grab a free month of HV1 from the folks who have brought you substantive local news since 1972. We made it 50 years thanks to support from readers like you. Help us keep real journalism alive.
- Geddy Sveikauskas, Publisher

Crispin Kott

Crispin Kott was born in Chicago, raised in New York and has called everywhere from San Francisco to Los Angeles to Atlanta home. A music historian and failed drummer, he’s written for numerous print and online publications and has shared with his son Ian and daughter Marguerite a love of reading, writing and record collecting.

 Crispin Kott is the co-author of the Rock and Roll Explorer Guide to New York City (Globe Pequot Press, June 2018), the Little Book of Rock and Roll Wisdom (Lyons Press, October 2018), and the Rock and Roll Explorer Guide to San Francisco and the Bay Area (Globe Pequot Press, May 2021).

Related Posts

Feds are pushing 5G; Woodstock might not want it
Politics & Government

Who in Woodstock town management is slacking off?

August 2, 2025
Feds are pushing 5G; Woodstock might not want it
Politics & Government

Woodstock town bills are paid

August 1, 2025
Woodstock councilmembers seek additional information from town supervisor
Politics & Government

Woodstock councilmembers seek additional information from town supervisor

July 31, 2025
Texas Attorney General sues Ulster County Clerk over New Paltz abortion pill provider case
Politics & Government

Texas Attorney General sues Ulster County Clerk over New Paltz abortion pill provider case

July 30, 2025
Politics & Government

Citing safety concerns, three Woodstock town board members won’t be attending Thursday’s meeting

July 29, 2025
Stormy Woodstock meeting questions the town supervisor’s original appointment
Politics & Government

Woodstock officials find plentiful fault with each other

July 30, 2025
Next Post
Woodstock police officer gets paid to do nothing

Defendant’s new lawsuit delays Woodstock police disciplinary case 

Weather

Kingston, NY
57°
Clear
5:51 am8:12 pm EDT
Feels like: 57°F
Wind: 1mph E
Humidity: 93%
Pressure: 30.12"Hg
UV index: 0
TueWedThu
86°F / 63°F
81°F / 63°F
81°F / 59°F
powered by Weather Atlas

Subscribe

Independent. Local. Substantive. Subscribe now.

  • Subscribe & Support
  • Print Edition
  • HV1 Magazines
  • Contact
  • Our Newsletters
  • Manage HV1 Account
  • Free HV1 Trial

© 2022 Ulster Publishing

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Schools
    • Business
    • Sports
    • Crime
    • Politics & Government
  • What’s Happening
    • Calendar Of Events
    • Art
    • Books
    • Kids
    • Lifestyle & Wellness
    • Food & Drink
    • Music
    • Nature
    • Stage & Screen
  • Opinions
    • Letters
    • Columns
  • Local
    • Special Sections
    • Local History
  • Marketplace
    • All Classified Ads
    • Post a Classified Ad
  • Obituaries
  • Subscribe & Support
  • Contact Us
    • Customer Support
    • Advertise
    • Submit A News Tip
  • Print Edition
    • Read ePaper Online
    • Newsstand Locations
    • Where’s My Paper
  • HV1 Magazines
  • Manage HV1 Account
  • Log In
  • Free HV1 Trial
  • Subscribe to Our Newsletters
    • Hey Kingston
    • New Paltz Times
    • Woodstock Times
    • Week in Review

© 2022 Ulster Publishing