Sister of man killed at Saugerties intersection says village isn’t doing enough to protect pedestrians

(Photo by Will Dendis)

Dinah Carlson, whose brother Robert was struck and killed by a motor vehicle while trying to cross Partition Street in January 2014, told the Saugerties village board’s Monday, May 15 meeting that enough was not being done to protect pedestrians on Partition and Main streets.

Mayor William Murphy told Carlson that he believes the village had done quite a bit to make the center of Saugerties safer for pedestrians and motorists. “We’ve made plenty of changes,” he said. “The state put up a bunch of yellow signs at the crosswalks warning of pedestrians. I disagree that we have done nothing.”

Carlson said that vehicles were turning right on red at the intersection of Main and Partition streets even though there are signs that say ‘No Turn on Red,’ and pedestrians are not always crossing through the intersection despite the crosswalk signs saying not to cross. “Traffic is going too fast through there,” Carlson added.


She did note the pedestrian crossing controls at the intersection were there because of her brother’s death and the action of the trustees and Saugerties police department in getting the state to install the ‘Walk’ and ‘Don’t Walk’ signs.

She said the lone, battered sign in the middle of Main Street that reminds drivers to stop for pedestrians was not enough.

Mayor Murphy said that at one time there had been two, but motorists kept running over the signs and one became too damaged to use. He added that Partition was a congested street, but it is also a state road and the village did not have the authority to make many changes there.

Carlson suggested eliminating some parking, but Murphy said any time that suggestion has been made the merchants along the street have protested.

“You can’t fix stupid,” the mayor said about pedestrians not paying attention to traffic, “especially when people walk out between cars to cross the street.”

Trustee Jeff Helmuth added the state DOT installed the traffic lights at the intersection in a way that made them difficult to see from vehicles. He said the lights should be over the road and not over the crosswalks.

“I’ve been a police officer for 30 years,” said police chief Joseph Sinagra, “and most adults and kids know that you have to look both ways when crossing the street.”

Pedestrians know enough to push the buttons at the crosswalks to get across the street but then they cross before the ‘Walk’ sign comes on. “The need to wait for the sign,” Sinagra said.

“We’re also doing more traffic safety education,” Sinagra noted, but the police can’t make people pay attention.

Carlson said she wasn’t sure what the solution to the problem is, but urged trustees and police to try and do more. “I don’t want my brother’s death to have been in vain,” she added.

There are 6 comments

  1. anthony kordich

    Pedestrians need to take responsibility for themselves. Stop look both ways, use crosswalks when available. Did they stop teaching that to children. Wow people are so ignorant.

    1. Tandy Sturgeon

      You do realize, genius, that you are referring in this case to someone who DIED trying to cross a badly marked street… have a nice life.

  2. Lisa

    I drive through this section of town several times a week and EVERY single time there is someone not crossing in the proper area, stepping into traffic, not waiting for the crosswalk. I am ALL about yielding for pedestrians and do whatever I can to keep them safe, however when they walk in front of your moving vehicle they are endangering themselves. I am VERY sad for the loss of life in any of these situations but what about the drivers that ARE obeying the laws and now their life’s are changed forever due to someone’s poor choices?? No one wants to be accountable for their actions anymore.

  3. Tim Sturgeon

    “You can’t fix stupid,” the mayor said about pedestrians not paying attention to traffic…

    The problem I’ve noticed is that the stop line is too far back from the intersection. So when the light turns green vehicles (lots of trucks on the state highway) can get up a head of steam by the time they get to the corner, and if they come around and someone is in the street they can’t stop in time. This is what happened to Mr. Carlson. Partition St. is very congested now, especially since it has become popular with tourists and restaurant goers. For Mayor Murphy to have this attitude is not only cruel, but, can I say it?: “Stupid.” He should work with the highway department on a range of ideas for making the city better for pedestrians. (Why not bring the stop line on Main St. — east bound — up to the crosswalk?) Mayor Murphy should be focused on building on Saugerties’ success. He should push the state to cooperate on changes to the intersection or even on re-routing 9W. Show some leadership. Be creative. Be determined. Support your community. Shame on you! That goes for you too Chief Sinagra…

Comments are closed.