City Democratic convention: The Nobles get the nods

Kathy Mihm counts votes as Tom Hoffay and Andy Zweben monitor. (Photo: Phyllis McCabe)

Kathy Mihm counts votes as Tom Hoffay and Andy Zweben monitor. (Photo: Phyllis McCabe)

Convening at the Best Western hotel Wednesday evening, the Kingston Democratic Committee voted to endorse Steve Noble over incumbent Shayne Gallo for mayor and incumbent Jim Noble over challenger Jeanette Provenzano for alderman-at-large.

In the weighted voting system used to tally the balloting among city committee members, Steve Noble, a city environmental programs manager and environmental educator, got 1,365 votes; Gallo, seeking his second term in office, got 1,045. Jim Noble, the longtime alderman-at-large and Steve Noble’s uncle, fended off Provenzano, who’s stepping away from the county legislature after 22 years, by a vote of 1,609-748.


In the contested Common Council ward races, newcomer Doug Koop beat Ward 2 incumbent Alderman Brian Seche 1,533-886. In a Ward 6 tussle between newcomers (two-term incumbent Elisa Ball declined to run for re-election), middle-school social studies teacher Tony Davis edged Hale Advisers account executive Alex Panagiotopoulos 1,239-1176.

Other unchallenged Common Council nominees were as follows: In Ward 1, Marist College professor Lynn Eckerd was tapped to succeed Majority Leader Matt Dunn, who also opted to not run again. In Ward 3, incumbent Brad Will was the only nominee. In Ward 4, incumbent Nina Dawson got the nod after the nomination of Daniel Kanter failed to receive a second. In Ward 5, incumbent Bill Carey was nominated without a challenge. In Ward 7, former alderman and council majority leader Bill Reynolds was nominated after incumbent Maryann Mills failed to receive a second. In Ward 8, incumbent Steve Schabot, nominated by Gallo and seconded by Provenzano, got the nod without challenge. In Ward 9, Lynn Johnson, who lost to Republican Deborah Brown two years ago, was nominated without challenge. (“[She’s] the pride of West Chester Street,” said Bob Gollnick, who seconded her nomination.)

All the candidates who got committee endorsements Wednesday aren’t guaranteed lines on the ballot for the September primary. (The state legislature has yet to set the exact date for the primary.) They have to get sufficient signatures for their nominating petitions, but the nominees’ petitions can be carried by Democratic committee members, presumably giving them an edge. Challengers will have to get enough signatures on nominating petitions of their own to get a spot on the primary ballot.

Four years ago, Hayes Clement won the committee nod for mayor over Shayne Gallo, but Gallo forced a primary. Gallo beat Clement by a handful of votes on primary day and went on to crush GOP nominee Ron Polacco in the general election.

“I feel great,” Steve Noble said after his win. “It’s a great endorsement to have, being a relative newcomer to the party. … We’re expecting a primary, so we’re going to be getting out there, knocking on doors, getting signatures and letting people know who I am. The best part of tonight is that it leads to the next step.”

“I want to thank those who nominated [former mayor Jim Sottile] me and seconded [by Karen Markisenis] me and I want to thank all the members of the city committee who had the confidence and faith to support me as their nominee,” Jim Noble said, adding that he was looking forward to running with his nephew. (Earlier this year, he said he would not run if Gallo got the nod.) “He brings a whole new side of Kingston, as far as his environmental views, his energy, his vitality as a young person,” he added, noting that Steve has brought in a lot of grant money and saved the city thousands with its recycling program.

As for the incumbent, Gallo expressed confidence that he would prevail in the primary and said he would run on his record. “I’ll keep pursuing initiatives like the Greenline, bringing back Broadway, seeking funding for new initiatives like the Cedar Street project and continuing to try to stimulate investment in the industrial park.”

Gallo also took a swipe at his foe. “He’s a reflection of a group of old-boy crony Democrats who want to go back to the four years that were prior and a time where people were disconnected to their party and disconnected to their government.”

Provenzano accused city committee Chairman Joe Donaldson of “stacking the committee” and vowed to primary Noble in September. “I still think I can win,” she said.


There are 17 comments

      1. gberke

        Hassle? Hassle? providing ms Bennett with what you have is a hassle? my my.
        Yes: The title of “Admin” is quite on the mark.

  1. Jen Fuentes

    Dem Committee members must run for their position through a nomination process that occurs every other year. Any democrat can run and in several cases last year there was a ward primary. I was pleased to see that level of interest because normally the seats go uncontested. In fact the republicans have numerous vacant seats from my understanding. I encouraged a friend of mine to run – Janai McDonough because she is very community minded. A few young people also came on board which is very promising. Feel free to private message me for more details on how to become more active.
    I see a Dem Committee headed in a very positive direction. Like any institution change does not occur over night. Disparaging the committee members feels a lot like sour grapes.

    1. Lynn Johnson

      Jen, Thanks for this explanation of what the Dem Committee is and does. Members are expected to attend monthly meetings, to carry petitions for Democratic candidates, and to work at election time on canvassing and phone banks to help Democrats get elected. This is the nuts and bolts work of democracy. Committee members do not always agree with one another, in fact we often disagree. But after the primary, we’ll come together to support the Democratic ticket. Lynn Johnson

  2. nopolitics

    Like any institution, sometimes it feels like the folks therein are IN an institution, Jen–or at least belong there.

  3. Timeforachange

    Ms. Bennett is a Gallo neophyte who only knows one thing. You are either with Gallo or you’re an enemy. It is the way Gallo does business, follow blindly, fight anyone who disagrees and always, always criticize a dissenting opinion. Ms. Bennett maybe you should do your own homework and get the information yourself!

    1. Janice Bennett

      Mayor Gallo is a fine man with a touch of anger now and then. I know him well because I am a member of his Senior committee and he does always help us. I am also a member of Midtown Rising, which is a group that is trying to make a better place to live in midtown and he is behind us all the way, as he is with other citizen groups. Just take a look at Broadway, it is a hell of a lot better then 4 yrs ago.
      also I am not afraid to give my REAL name

      1. Susan

        Janice, I wholeheartedly agree with you. Midtown is finally getting the attention it needs, thanks to the Gallo Administration. Gallo doesn’t mince his words, he tells it like it is.

  4. Rainier Parade

    If Gallo is going to run on his record, he will lose. His tenure has been an unmitigated disaster for the city. Just take a drive down Washington Avenue if you don’t believe me. And the Democrats have apparently seen enough. Gallo, as an incumbent, can’t even win a majority of his own party. What does that tell you? It’s time for new leadership.

    1. nopolitics

      Now, what HAS Gallo done about the speed bump on the corner of Flatbush and Penn Court, that violates the basic precepts of road engineering by placing it at an intersection, reported the end of September of last year, in the wake of all the CHIPS money coming from the state for road repair? I will tell you…EL ZIPPO, NADA, NOTHING, EL ZILCHO. Sottile’s wonderful appointee Mr. Schupp and “that giant Schupping sound”!!! What has he DONE about the fact there are no SIGNS designating Colonial Drive a SCHOOL ZONE? Same thing. What has Alderman Ball done? Same thing. That’s great he has done something for midtown, now what about sidetown? This is all a CLOWN show, and the biggest clown looks like a pelican!!! The Nobles are also the McGrane family updated to this era. That’s it!!! Rather…umm…riiiii—idiculous!!!!

Post Your Thoughts